Exotic car ownership has always been about more than speed and status—it’s about passion, engineering, and sometimes, smart investing. While not all supercars appreciate over time, certain models have proven to hold their value exceptionally well, especially when bought at the right time with the right specs. Whether you're looking for a weekend driver that won't lose its luster or a collectible that may become a future classic, these exotic cars are among the best to buy right now for long-term value.
Ferrari 812 Superfast
As Ferrari continues its shift toward hybrid powertrains and smaller displacement engines, the naturally aspirated V12 is becoming a rarer breed. The 812 Superfast, with its 789-horsepower 6.5L V12, represents the pinnacle of front-engine Ferrari performance. Its classic proportions, raw power, and limited production numbers make it one of the last great analog-feeling Ferraris. Well-optioned examples with low mileage are already showing signs of strong residual value and may see appreciation as the V12 era winds down.
Lamborghini Aventador Ultimae
The Aventador was Lamborghini’s flagship V12 platform for over a decade, and the Ultimae was the final evolution. With only a limited number produced, this special edition combines the raw power of the SVJ with a more refined and luxurious execution. As the last naturally aspirated V12 Lamborghini before the hybridized Revuelto, the Ultimae is a collector's dream—and prices are likely to rise in the years ahead.
Porsche 911 GT3 Touring (992 Generation)
Though not as flashy as a mid-engine exotic, the 911 GT3 Touring offers a pure, engaging driving experience with Porsche reliability and build quality. Its naturally aspirated flat-six engine, six-speed manual transmission, and limited production volume create strong demand. Historically, GT and Touring models from Porsche have retained their value better than most, and the latest 992 version is poised to follow suit.
Ferrari 458 Italia
The 458 marked the end of an era as the last naturally aspirated mid-engine V8 Ferrari. It blends timeless styling, mechanical emotion, and Ferrari’s iconic high-revving engine into a package that’s becoming more sought-after each year. Prices have remained strong, especially for low-mileage examples with premium options and carbon packages. As newer turbocharged and hybrid models take over, the 458’s status as a modern classic continues to grow.
McLaren 765LT
The McLaren 765LT is one of the most extreme, track-focused supercars available with road-legal status. Its limited production run, race-inspired design, and blistering performance have made it a standout in McLaren’s modern lineup. With McLaren’s newer models shifting toward electrification, the 765LT may represent a high point in pure combustion-engine performance for the brand. Its rarity and track pedigree give it strong potential for long-term value.
Pagani Huayra (Coupe or Roadster)
Pagani's handcrafted hypercars exist in a category of their own. With extremely limited production, exquisite materials, and a reputation for artistic design, the Huayra has all the hallmarks of a long-term collectible. Every example is bespoke, and the AMG-built V12 paired with a unique single-clutch transmission gives the car a raw and mechanical feel that’s increasingly rare. These cars already carry a premium—but their exclusivity means they’re not likely to lose value any time soon.
Ferrari SF90 Stradale (Spec-Dependent)
While hybrid exotics are still a new frontier, the Ferrari SF90 Stradale is gaining traction as a future icon. It's the first series-production plug-in hybrid from Ferrari, offering over 1,000 horsepower. While production isn’t ultra-limited, buyers who spec their SF90 carefully—especially with Assetto Fiorano package, lightweight options, and rare paint-to-sample colors—may find themselves with a highly desirable car in the near future. Time will tell, but the SF90 has the ingredients to age well.
Buying an exotic car for long-term value is part strategy, part timing, and part passion. Look for models that mark the end of an era, are produced in limited numbers, or offer something truly unique in terms of design or performance. Maintenance history, condition, and options all play a role, too.
At Boardwalk Auto Group, we specialize in sourcing and selling exceptional exotic vehicles. Whether you're looking to buy an investment-grade Ferrari or a collectible Lamborghini to enjoy on weekends, we can help you find the right car with the right story. Because long-term value isn’t just about money—it’s about owning something truly unforgettable.